Large site logo

To Open The Sky

The Front Pages of Christopher P. Winter
Work in progress
Netanyahu's war in Iran is based on lies.
Indicted War Criminal Netanyahu's war in Iran puts world at risk.
Ben Norton, Geopolitical Economy Report, 4 March 2026
Effing Fool DJT
Updated 30 July 2026

Background

At least since he came to power in 1996, and probably before that, Benjamin Netanyahu has regarded the Islamic Republic of Iran as the greatest threat to Israel. There is some justification for this: The Mullahs who led Iran since 1979 have sponsored proxy groups that regularly attacked Israel with rockets and suicide bombers. The broader historical view, however, leads to a different view. Before Israel was created by Britain under the auspices of the United Nations in 1948, Muslims and Jews coexisted peacefully in the Middle East. Zionist militants before and during Israel's formation expelled hundreds of thousands of Palestinians from lands they had occupied for generations. Israel's current government regards Palestinians as subhuman. I won't rehash that history here; see the link at the bottom of this page for details.

What matters here is that Netanyahu has consistently used this claim that Iran is a huge threat to justify his belligerent actions in the region — most notably Israel's occupation of Gaza and the West Bank. He recently admitted that the war begun against Iran in February 2026 is the fulfillment of a dream he has harbored for 40 years. I suspect that what he considers a dream will turn out to be a nightmare for the people of Israel. But they have repeatedly chosen Netanyahu to lead them. Now they have to live with the consequences.

The United States does not. It has myopically supported Israel for too long, through both Republican and Democratic administrations. Trump's advent brings US support for Israel down to the level of total blindness, as he now embarks on a war of whim with no approval from Congress, no clear goals, no strategic planning, and insufficient ammunition stocks for a protracted conflict. Here I will show why this is politically, militarily, legally, and environmentally stupid.

Political Stupidity

  • The first act of this war was an air strike on the buildings where Ayatollah Ali Khamenei was meeting with Iran's other leaders. He and some 40 others were killed. This makes Khamenei, a sacred figure to Shia Muslims, a martyr. They will want revenge.
  • Among the other leaders killed in this strike were some who Trump hoped might take Khamenei's place. Their loss makes a hardliner replacement more likely.
  • There was apparently no preplanning about how to help American citizens in the area get home. Thousands of them were stranded at the beginning of the conflict. The State Department resorted to advising them on bus travel.
  • Domestically, this betrays Trump's promise not to start foreign wars.
  • Iran's closing of the Strait of Hormuz also raises the cost of gasoline in the US at a time when Trump's tariffs are already raising prices.

Military Stupidity

  • The claimed reasons for this war are lies. Iran was not pursuing nuclear weapons, has no missiles that can reach the US, and had offered a better deal on uranium than the JCPOA contained.
  • The US was not negotiating in good faith. Cheating invites reprisals.
  • Trump and Hegseth underestimated both Iran's resolve and its weapons stockpiles, and apparently ignored the Joint Chiefs' advice on this.
  • Trump and Hegseth also ignored how limited are the stocks of critical US weaponry, and how difficult they will be to replace.

Legal Stupidity

  • This war is illegal per US law, because Congress was not consulted and the claimed imminent threat does not exist.
  • This war is illegal under international law, and ignoring that fact creates a precedent for other countries to also ignore it.
  • Executive Order 12333, signed by Ronald Reagan, prohibits any member of the US government "from planning, directing, aiding, or carrying out assassinations."
  • Attacking civilian infrastructure which is not being used by enemy forces is a war crime. The elementary school bombed in Minab falls under this prohibition. Evidence indicates the strike was done by the US.
  • The US has also attacked oil storage facilities and water desalination plants in Iran. These are war crimes that put civilians at risk.

Environmental Stupidity

  • Military operations are among the largest sources of greenhouse gases, and this war will certainly increase those operations.
  • Intentional destruction of pipelines, refineries, tankers, or oil and gas wells releases large amounts of methane and carbon dioxide, both greenhouse gases.
  • Spilled oil is also a pollutant damaging to humans, domestic animals and wildlife, and a persistent one.

Extra-special Stupidity

  • Some 50 unit commanders in our military told their troops this war was necessary to bring on the Rapture.

All of this was understood by our military leaders beforehand. Independent experts understood it as well, and you can find observations from some of them in the list of sources below. The war in Vietnam (1955-1975), The Iran-Iraq War (1980-1988), the war in Iraq (2003-2011), the campaign against the Houthis in Yemen (March-May 2025) — all provided lessons that our current leaders are ignoring.1

Details of the conflict are hard to obtain from the Trump Regime. Their statements typically consist of macho posturing. But here is a developing summary of the progress of this war — for it surely is a war, despite the blatherings of Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt and Rep. Ana Paulina Luna.

Americans at home learned of this war in the early morning of Saturday, 28 February 2026.2 The first act was a salvo of strikes on the buildings where Iran's government leaders routinely meet. Most were there at the time. The Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, and 49 others were killed. Also on Saturday came the strike on an elementary school in Minab, in the south of Iran. This reportedly bordered an IRGC naval base. At least 164 people were killed, most of them young girls. Evidence suggests it was a US strike based on intelligence that was outdated by ten years.3

Over the next several days, the US and Israel continued intense bombardment all over Iran, achieving air superiority and claiming they were steadily eliminating missile factories and launch sites. Details are not forthcoming, but reports indicate 3 more schools and several hospitals were also hit.

The war Trump thought would be over in a week or less has lasted six months and hovers on the verge of expanding. Trump alternates between claiming Iran is begging for a peace deal because we've eliminated all their weapons and insisting they will be hit even harder if they don't agree to open the Strait and promise never to develop nuclear weapons. Iran will do neither in the near future; it still has plenty of weapons, is building more, and is politically stronger now than before Trump started his foolish war of choice. The conflict is till far from resolution.

At the end of July, Netanyahu, desperate to continue his war on Iran, came again to the US to exhort Trump to stay the course — even as US stockpiles of interceptors and standoff munitions dwindle.4 Netanyahu took the time for a round of interviews, going on air to denounce New York City's popular mayor. This triggered prominent Israel supporters to resume calling the ICC "a fake court" and saying Zohran Mamdani, in calling for Netanyahu's arrest, was indulging in "stupid theatrics" and "literally trying to destroy the policy of the United States."

Zionist Aggression

  • The Iranian frigate Dena, reportedly carrying no weapons, was returning from joint exercises with India. A torpedo from a US submarine struck it near Sri Lanka. The crew of the submarine made no attempt to rescue any of the crew aboard. Ships from Sri Lanka saved some of its crew complement of 130, but 87 are known dead and more are missing.
  • Reports are that 7 schools, 18 hospitals, and a 12,000-seat stadium have been struck in Iran.
  • On 7 March, the US attacked the water desalination plant on Qeshm Island, putting 30 Iranian villages in water shortage and inviting retaliation against similar plants.
  • Israel has essentially taken over southern Lebanon, forcing residents to flee and then destroying their homes. Christian villages are not immune. Even Beirut has been hit multiple times. Several possible ceasefires with Iran have been derailed when Israel resumed attacks on Lebanon.

Iran's Retaliation

Iran's retaliation began quickly. Among the targets it has struck are:

  • US Navy 5th Fleet HQ, Bahrain
  • Al Udeid Air Base, Qatar
  • A powerful radar site in Jordan that controls part of Israel's "Iron Dome."
  • Three launch sites for THAAD (Theater High-Altitude Air Defense) interceptor missiles
  • According to The Independent, "Blasts were reported in Jerusalem, Dubai, Abu Dhabi in UAE, Doha in Qatar, and Manama in Bahrain as the conflict entered its third day."
  • The US Embassy in Kuwait was hit, and later evacuated.
  • Three US F-15 fighter jets were downed by Kuwait in what was called a friendly fire incident.
  • A US F-35 stealth fighter was damaged over Iran on 19 March 2026. It made an emergency landing at a US base. The pilot was not injured.
  • Iranian missiles brought down a US F-15E fighter over Iran on 3 April 2026. Both occupants ejected. Both were rescued; the pilot almost immediately, the weapons officer after an extensive search.
  • More than 170 US and Israeli drones were downed, destroyed or crippled by Iran's air defenses.
What are the Implications?

Implications for the Combatants

After being attacked twice in the middle of what it thought were good-faith negotiations, and after suffering the decapitation of its government and general attacks on its civilian population, Iran will be in no mood to negotiate further — despite the desperate lies of the Trump Regime. It will continue to inflict as much pain as it can on Israel, the US, and their allies around the Persian Gulf. And recent days have shown it is capable of inflicting considerable pain.

The US and Israel will be forced to rethink their overall strategy. They have not been able to force the regime change they wanted in Iran; rather, the regime change they got was from a hard-line regime to a harder-line regime — and one leading a populace newly embittered by a fresh wave of atrocities. These two aggressor nations have also earned the displeasure of their own people and of the wider world.

Implications for the Muslim community

The assassination of Ayatollah Ali Khamenei turned him into a martyr, inflaming the Shia sect of Muslims. It very probably also raised the likelihood of conflicts between Shia and Sunnis.

Implications for the world in general

The wider world can expect to face an accelerated timetable for problems that were already in the offing. These include short-term shortages of food and fuel, increased flows of refugees, and the disruptions due to climate change. In addition, it will have to deal with an increasingly lawless world as rogue states follow the precedent set by Israel and the US.

Implications for the environment

The world will see a general worsening of droughts, floods, heat waves, and extreme storms. Pests and tropical diseases will spread, and food insecurity will increase.

The Bottom Line

The bottom line is that, once again, the stupidity and corruption of the Trump Regime have made things much worse than they needed to be.

Airports in the region were shut down, leaving many Americans and other travelers stranded.

Several oil tankers were struck in the Strait of Hormuz, and Iran officially closed the Strait, through which 20% of the world's oil is shipped. The prices of petroleum products immediately began to rise. The Strait is also a choke point for shipments of fertilizer and helium. Loss of the fertilizer affected crop planting around the globe, and helium is critical for semiconductor chip manufacture.

The Houthis in Yemen and Hezbollah in Lebanon also entered the fight, firing missiles and drones they were not supposed to have.

The Iranian frigate Dena, returning from exercises with India, was sunk near Sri Lanka by a torpedo from a US submarine. Ships from Sri Lanka rescued 66 of its 130 crew; 87 perished.

The US claims 44 ships of Iran's navy have been sunk, and says it has eliminated most of Iran's missile launchers. Given the strength of Iran's retaliation, this looks like false bravado.

Iran is a large country with a population of over 90 million people, most of whom now hate the US. Committing US ground troops there would be sending them to be slaughtered.

The great majority of Americans also hate this war. The Trump Regime's candidates are unlikely to do well in coming elections.

CURRENT STATUS OF TRUMP'S WAR OF CHOICE WITH IRAN

2 August 2026

This pointless war with Iran has killed 18 service members, wounded more than 100, and cost upwards of $113 billion so far. Trump continues to shift positions on the conflict like a weathervane in a gale. Hegseth continues refusing to give Congress straight answers.

Forecasts predict rising consumer prices, falling poll numbers for the Trump Regime and for politicians who support it, and a 50% chance of escalation with more death on both sides.

Extended Discussion

Here I present some sources that are especially good at explaining the various risks of this illegal war of aggression.

Why is the war illegal?

Trump Started a War. Congress Just Watched.
(Sarah Longwell, The Bulwark, 7 March 2026)

What are the latest developments?

Latest Analysis: War with Iran
(Center for Strategic & International Studies)

US Middle East Policy

US policy in the Middle East has often coincided with Israel's, and in many cases contrary to US interests. Nowhere is this more true than for US policy toward the Islamic Republic of Iran. Israel's leaders, and most markedly Netanyahu, have long regarded Iran as their chief adversary. There is some basis for this: Following the overthrow of the brutal Shah Reza Pahlavi in the Islamic Revolution of 1979, Iran has been a theocracy led by the Shia wing of Islam. It sponsors terrorist proxy groups in various nations, including Hamas in Gaza, Hezbollah in Lebanon, and the Houthis in Yemen. These groups have regularly attacked Israel. Since 2003, Iran has undertaken to develop nuclear power, and it is this that Netanyahu dreads the most. He has consistently overstated Iran's ability and intent to develop nuclear weapons, on several occasions fabricating evidence of this — sometimes with US help. In 2015, he tried unsuccessfully to derail the Obama administration's negotiation (along with European nations) of an agreement with Iran which monitored and limited Iran's enrichment of uranium. After Trump took power in 2016, he was able to persuade the new US leader to unilaterally pull out of this multinational agreement, known as the JCPOA. The Biden administration tried to restore it, but Iran understandably held back. It threw out the monitors and soon had uranium enriched to 60%: near weapons grade. Netanyahu, characteristically, tried to claim Iran was weeks away from having nuclear weapons. In 2025, during US-Iran talks, Netanyahu ordered air strikes on Iran's nuclear sites and persuaded Trump to join in with its massive "bunker busters." Despite Trump's insistent claims, these strikes did not obliterate Iran's nuclear program. They did push the Middle East closer to general war.

On 28 February 2026 — once again during peace talks — Israel and the US attacked Iran. Depite killing the Ayatollah Ali Khamenei and 49 of Iran's leaders, these attacks did not topple the government of the Islamic Republic of Iran. In fact, its leadership turned more hardline against the West than it had been. And despite suffering widespread bombardment, including of schools, hospitals, and vital infrastructure such as water plants, Iran was able to strike multiple US military and commercial facilities in its neighboring countries. It caused massive damage which the US government tried to conceal. Iran also closed the Strait of Hormuz, a move predicted before this round of hostilities began. World commerce was impacted as a result, since roughly one-third of all oil and gas, and other vital commodities, flow through the Strait. These difficulties persist, largely because Israel continues its offensive against Hezbollah in Lebanon.

It's generally considered bad faith to conduct surprise attacks on countries while holding peace talks with them. But this is what Israel has repeatedly done. And now it has twice sucked the Trump Regime into doing the same.

This is an area where print references are especially useful.

My Reviews of Relevant Print References

Other Print References:

Sources:

I think the motivation for this complex situation is simply summarized: Netanyahu persuaded Trump to join the operation, and Trump was eager partly because of his success in Venezuela and partly because it serves as a distraction from other problems Trump faces — notably, the Epstein files. However, the outcome has only made things worse for Trump, for Israel, and for the world.

For more details on what Israel has been doing in Gaza, and how the US supports it, see this link:

1 I omit the 1990-1991 Gulf War, conducted by George H. W. Bush and the 42-nation "coalition of the willing" to expel Saddam Hussein's forces from Kuwait. This had two phases: Operation Desert Shield, running from August 1990 through January 1991, and Operation Desert Storm. The latter phase took just nine days: 17 through 28 January. President Bush wisely chose not to remove Saddam Hussein from power. See Gulf War (Wikipedia, 5 March 2026)
2 The Trump Regime followed the common tactic of releasing major news in the early hours of a weekend, when there would be less political outcry.
3 In early 2025, our "Secretary of War" Pete Hegseth, fired Petagon judge advocates general and shut down the Pentagon agency responsible for minimizing attacks on civilians.
4 US Admiral Bradley Cooper is advised by Mark Dubowitz of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, a pro-Israel think tank with a record of cultivating US military leaders and lobbying for Israel's objectives.
Valid CSS! Valid HTML 4.01 Strict To contact Chris Winter, send email to this address.
Copyright © 2025-2026 Christopher P. Winter. All rights reserved.
This page was last modified on 2 August 2026.